Micron Technology has struggled to wean its self off
producing nothing more than commodity DRAM in the last 18 months. However,
yesterday the Boise Idaho, based chip manufacturer caught many financial
analysts by surprise by producing a clear profit of the quarter instead of an
estimated $100 million loss.
At the core of Micron's quarterly performance was the sales
growth in non-commodity DRAM devices that are currently providing higher
margins than even DRAM-DDR2 chips. The CMOS image sensor business that really
only started two years ago is now supplying all top 20 mobile phone companies
and now holds the largest market share in that domain. Micron has seen its
image sensor business grow 200 percent year on year, with no warning that the
best has come and gone from that division.
Indeed, Micron's Steve Appleton remarked during the
conference call with financial analysts that margins from the image sensors
were the best within the company and due to its embedded technology leadership
of imaging on the chips he expects margins to remain high, even though
competition is getting tougher.
Furthermore, Appleton asserted that some of his competitors
in the CMOS image sensor business would struggle to stay in the market due to
poorer technical capabilities of their devices.
Even its NAND Flash has taken off, after being criticised as
"too little to late" compared with the Samsung's efforts in that
market.
Micron reported a five fold sales
increase, which isn't that bad compared to Infineon's proposed efforts!
Micron's Flash devices are being targeted at low power demanding
consumer
products such as MP3 players. Samsung would seem to have done Micron a
favour
in that market with its huge allocation dedicated to Apple's needs.
Indeed,
this was the first quarter where Micron saw "significant sales for the
first
time," so the Samsung/Apple supply deal has had a positive effect
almost
instantly!
The only drag on the financial performance would seem to be
DRAM DDR and DRAM DDR2. Although prices were flat in the quarter for DDR, after
severe drops in ASP's all year, DDR2 prices were falling due to over capacity
caused by slower than expected adoption by notebook and desktop PC vendors.
Micron, though may be fighting back in this area, as its
manufacturing cost reduction programs, coupled to improved yields and output at
its Manassas based 300mm fab is progressing a little better than projections,
according to Appleton. Even its speciality DRAM product range was doing well
with ASP's higher than even NAND Flash.
Toggling Capacity
Its all well and good, designing and manufacturing devices
outside the traditional core products, the hard part it giving those new
products enough future capacity to grow with the potential demand. Often one
product range is sacrificed for another and never really recovers from that
point forward. A diversified product portfolio takes a different level of
discipline and needs time to be learnt.
This was one of deep pits Micron could have fallen into over
the last year, but it seems now that the risk has been reduced, though it must
be said, has not be eliminated. It was not surprising to here from Micron
executives that it was playing a fine balancing act between manufacturing
allocation, product demand and product gross margins.
Both Hynix and Samsung have been toggling production at fabs
between NAND and DRAM for the last 18 months, as NAND has been commanding
higher ASP's than DRAM. In Micron's case the toggling is a little more complex
to manage as it has specialty DRAM as well as CMOS image sensors, both holding
up better in both ASP's and gross margins. Yet NAND is obviously a larger
market and demand will continue to be strong for sometime to come. Micron it
seems has resisted the urge to switch more than it so far has to NAND, and is
currently more interested in protecting its image sensor market and margins
over other products within its portfolio.
DRAM allocation would seem to be close to passing a tough
crossroads. Micron has switched 200mm DRAM production over to new products
incrementally, while limiting the drop in revenues from the historical volume
part of the business. This could have gone horribly wrong with poor new product
sales couple to reductions in volume revenue DRAM. Micron's 300mm fab played an
important part in averting that scenario, as it would now seem that fab is
reaching very good yields at the same time as ramping aggressively. Appleton
remarked that future DRAM capacity will come from its 300mm fab via ramping
slightly further but more from die shrinks being planned.
Both NAND and DRAM manufacturing costs are also expected to
continue to fall, adding to the bottom line, according to Appleton. Even its
sister fabs at TECH Semiconductor in Singapore have been pushing cost reduction
strategies, which have come through in the last quarter to the tune of a 20 to
25 percent improvement.
Toggling capex
Capital expenditure at Micron has always been tight.
However, the level of diversity it has been able to achieve means that going
forward more money will need to be allocated to capacity and technology
development. Capex for 2005 came through at $1.3 billion US dollars, just about
as much as the company could afford without reducing its cash savings.
However, Micron stated that capex for 2006 will be in the
range of $1 to 1.5 billion US dollars. More money will be required to develop
NAND Flash, while funds will be needed to expand 300mm production and migrate
to the next feature size. CMOS image sensors also need cash for capacity
increases, which will be a boon for its Avezzano Fab in Italy. CMOS image
sensors are Micron's "primary growth market," so attention is naturally staying
in this area.
All in all, Micron's strategy of diversification is paying
off, and starting to pay off well. The company will have to maintain a tight
financial ship in 2006, but if they continue executing the way they have in a
tough climate other bonuses could come through in 2008.
One key potential bonus is finally utilising its Lehi (300mm
ready) fab for chip production. Appleton responded to a question about Lehi,
just like he does every conference call, but his response was the most
optimistic yet!
Though he dismissed the possibility of using the fab in the
next financial year, he did say that the time is coming closer and closer when
they would use the facility for 300mm production. Based on our own 300mm fab
capacity tracking, an announcement from Micron could happen in the second
quarter of next year, as the Manassas fab would be reaching capacity later in
the year. As new cleanroom construction is not required the fab could be
operational 10 months after placing Lithography tool orders. Those orders could
be place in early 2006 and still not come out of the capex budget for that
year!
With this week's $33 billion dollar capex binge by Samsung,
spread over the next seven years, its not surprising Micron started
diversifying a few years ago. All they need to do now is keep on toggling!
|